Derby

Derby & Burton Hospitals: Stillbirth and baby death deepdive

today10 November 2026

Background
share close

A “deep dive” into dozens of baby deaths and stillbirths at Derby and Burton’s hospitals has found “potentially” avoidable deaths, two years after an investigation found numerous maternity care shortfalls.

The University Hospitals of Derby and Burton NHS Foundation Trust has launched a “deep dive” into neonatal – newborn babies up to 28 days old – deaths between 2023 and 2026.

It has also said that every stillbirth from 2024 to the present was being proactively reviewed.

A review has found that there has been an increase in the number of extremely premature babies, younger than 24 weeks (six months), rather than a rise in improper care.

However, it did find space for “potential” actions which may have affected outcomes – avoided deaths.

In a trust board meeting today (Tuesday, November 10), Sarah Noble, the director of midwifery, stressed no safety concerns had been highlighted by the review.

She said a number of stillbirths had taken place before the mothers came to hospital.

Ms Noble said many of the deaths related to babies on the “cusp of viability” and beyond the expertise of Royal Derby, a Level 2 maternity unit, and requiring the specialist support of staff in Nottingham, which is better prepared as a higher level unit, to handle cases of babies younger than 27 weeks.

She said in the last quarter, 15 babies were transferred from Derby to Nottingham and in a third of those cases (circa five babies), “there was something we could have done earlier to get that transfer sooner”.

Ms Noble said there was a lack of capacity for this highly specialist level of maternity care and relied entirely on support outside of the trust in the wider region and further afield.

The latest review comes two years after the trust published a review into 157 baby deaths between January 1st, 2020 to March 31st, 2023.

The outcome of that review found “learning” from investigations was not being embedded, with repeated and continued issues with “fetal monitoring interpretation, women reporting reduced fetal movements and subsequent care, documentation, and communication issues”.

It found a consistent failure to follow local or national maternity guidelines across all parts of the service, through pregnancy to aftercare for the mother and baby.

That report found care issues that “may” have affected the outcome for the baby in 16 cases, with a “likely” impact in 11 further cases, prompting a trust apology, which said it “could and should have done better”.

Now, the trust says in its board report, released this week, that while its perinatal mortality rate (babies from pregnancy to one-year-old baby) and stillbirth rate remain below the national average, there has been a “noted increase” in deaths from November 2025 until July 2026, with a small “spike” for neonatal deaths,  prompting a review of 61 neonatal deaths between 2023 to 2026 – to the current date.

Its deep-dive found a large proportion of the deaths relating to extremely premature births – before 24 weeks (six months) – accounting for 45.9 per cent of cases.

A full-term pregnancy is 40 weeks – 10 months.

The review found “recurring, potentially modifiable themes including timely recognition of threatened preterm birth, obstetric-neonatal decision-making, and escalation for in utero transfer, regional capacity constraints, interpreter use, documentation, and reliable completion of the optimisation pathway”.

It also found: “The available evidence suggests that variation in case mix, particularly the high proportion of extremely preterm births, is a significant contributor to the observed increase in deaths rather than a deterioration in the quality or safety of care.” 

Perinatal mortality rates for Asian and Black women continue to highlight disparities and this is reflected in national statistics, the review found.

The trust’s perinatal mortality rate stands at 4.4 per 1,000 births, below an average of 4.77.

It writes that its stillbirth rates have increased since July and that while also below the national average, “we are proactively reviewing all stillbirth cases from 2024 to present”.

A trust board report shows its stillbirth rate sat at 2.4 per 1,000 births in June, but has increased month on month to 2.89 in September, the most recent figure, lower than the national average of 3.18.

Neonatal death statistics had shown a “spike” above the national average in July 2026, at 1.64 per 1,000 births in July, above the average 1.6.

There have been 23 stillbirths since last October, the trust says, with four in July and three in August, compared with more than 600 successful births every month.

The trust says this has triggered its first Level 1 maternity outcomes safety signals system alert.

This means there is a 95 per cent chance the increase in “events” is real and not due to random chance.

The only other alert – Level 2 – is a 99 per cent chance the increase is real.

These alerts prompt a local team to perform a critical safety check of the relevant maternity services and rapid escalations aimed at improving outcomes for patients.

It confirms the Level 1 alert related to Royal Derby Hospital and was triggered by one neonatal death and two stillbirths of at-term babies in September, with no harm identified in terms of actions or inaction from the trust.

The trust writes: “While the review highlighted no immediate safety concerns, several areas for ongoing improvement were identified including the quality of handover, data compliance and the amount of time it took between making decisions and deliveries for category 1 and 2 c-sections. “

Meanwhile, the trust said that post-partum haemorrhages are above the national average at 39 per 1,000 births compared to 33 nationally, along with rates of third and fourth degree tears also above the national average at 36.68 per 1,000 births and 28 nationally.

A report to Derby City Council by the Derby and Derbyshire Integrated Care Board, which manages health services across the county and city, reads: “Overall, maternity services across Derby and Derbyshire continue to demonstrate progress in safety, leadership, service user engagement and delivery of national maternity priorities providing assurance that maternity and neonatal services safety has improved since 2023. 

“UHDB has made sustained improvements but continues to receive targeted support and scrutiny. Further improvement is required however, in relation to neonatal mortality trends, postpartum haemorrhage, severe perineal tears and consistent implementation of national safety requirements.”

Written by: Eddie Bisknell - Local Democracy Reporting Service


103.5 & 96.8 FM

LOVE MUSIC

LOVE EREWASH

Office: 0115 888 0968
Studio: 0115 930 3450

Erewash Sound, The Media Centre, 37 Vernon Street, Ilkeston, DE7 8PD

© Copyright 2026 Erewash Sound CIC. All Rights Reserved. Company Number 6658171.