Derbyshire

Derbyshire backs CCN call for fair, transparent and evidence-led local government reform

today16 November 2026

Background
share close

Derbyshire County Council has backed serious concerns raised by the County Councils Network over the Government’s handling of local government reorganisation, warning that changes to the process risk undermining evidence-based proposals, wasting taxpayers’ money and creating councils that may not be sustainable for the future.

Speaking from the County Councils Network (CCN) annual conference today (Monday 16th Novemner) Derbyshire County Council’s leader, Councillor Alan Graves said the county council supports the principle of local government reform where it can create better-run, more efficient councils, protect critical services and deliver better value for taxpayers.

But he added that concerns have grown over the way the process is now being conducted, particularly where the criteria councils were originally asked to work against appear to be receiving different weight as the Government considers the proposals before it.

These concerns have also been raised nationally by the CCN, whose Chair, leader of Lincolnshire County Council Councillor Sean Matthews warned in his conference speech this morning that the local government reorganisation (LGR) process had been repeatedly changed and the “goal posts moved”. He highlighted the enormous amounts of council time, money and resources already committed and called for a process that is robust, fair and transparent.

Councillor Graves said he believed the Government must also address the balance of its engagement over LGR.

He said: “Members of Parliament have an important democratic voice and should be part of the conversation. But the councils affected by reorganisation should have greater input because they are the subject-matter experts responsible for the services any future unitary authorities will have to inherit and sustain.

“Councils understand the finances, workforce, demand pressures and operational realities of delivering adult social care, children’s services, SEND, highways and many of the other critical services residents depend upon every day.

“Although greater engagement from the current Minister is welcomed, engagement must also mean listening to the evidence and concerns being presented by the councils responsible for delivering those services.’’

Councillor Graves added: “Government appears to have shifted the focus of local government reorganisation away from creating sustainable, efficient councils and towards housing growth and political expediency. That is a fundamental change, and Derbyshire residents deserve to understand why.

“The consequences matter. Get this wrong and we risk creating new councils that are financially unsustainable from day one, while putting even greater pressure on Derbyshire’s green belt and green spaces.

“If Government is genuinely committed to creating councils that are sustainable for the future, it must seriously consider the case for a single Derbyshire unitary. In our view, particularly in light of the Government’s new funding review, it is the only proposal on the table that offers the scale and resilience needed for the long term.

“I am calling on Government to be completely transparent about this process: what criteria are now being used, how they are being weighted, what evidence is informing decisions and why the approach appears to have changed.

“Derbyshire residents deserve a decision based on evidence, financial sustainability and the future of their services, not political expediency.”

Councillor Graves said: “Councils have invested significant officer time, expertise and public money in developing detailed proposals against the criteria set by Government.

“Changing the basis upon which those proposals are judged risks devaluing that work and raises legitimate questions about whether councils have been allowed to compete on a consistent basis.

“The issue is therefore not simply about structures or council boundaries. It is about whether the authorities created through LGR will have the financial resilience, workforce, scale and capacity to continue delivering essential public services for Derbyshire residents.’’

The County Councils Network has similarly warned against creating arrangements which could be more fragmented, more complex and more costly than the councils they replace and has called for decisions to be based on evidence rather than political or legal expediency.

Councillor Graves said: “Derbyshire County Council’s position is clear: reform should deliver stronger and more efficient councils, better services and better value for taxpayers, but achieving that requires a process that is robust, fair, transparent and evidence-led.

“Government should be open about the criteria ultimately being used to assess proposals, how those criteria are being weighted and the evidence underpinning its decisions.

“The expertise of councils responsible for delivering critical frontline services must have proper weight in that process. And the long-term financial consequences of each proposal need to be understood before irreversible decisions are taken.

“Ultimately, the test of local government reorganisation should not be which particular structure wins. It should be whether the councils created from it are financially sustainable, operationally deliverable and capable of protecting the services Derbyshire residents will rely upon for decades to come.’’

Written by: -


103.5 & 96.8 FM

LOVE MUSIC

LOVE EREWASH

Office: 0115 888 0968
Studio: 0115 930 3450

Erewash Sound, The Media Centre, 37 Vernon Street, Ilkeston, DE7 8PD

© Copyright 2026 Erewash Sound CIC. All Rights Reserved. Company Number 6658171.