Derbyshire

Fact check reveals the scale of pothole repairs in Derbyshire

today19 November 2026

Background
share close

A Derbyshire council has made significant progress regarding potholes and road repairs, stats show, but key false claims are still being widely dispersed by Reform UK.

There is a backlog of about 900 potholes, current stats from Derbyshire County Council show, with this level dropping far below the lowest reaches of 2025, when it fell to 3,100.

This stemmed from a high of 19,100 in early March 2025, followed by a much lower peak in March this year, of 11,600.

Those statistics show a marked change, under the Reform administration, in terms of achieving a much smaller backlog by the start of winter and a much lower peak at the start of spring.

However, despite these facts, Reform UK has sent its Reformer “newspaper” to all households in the UK this October, claiming, alongside a photo of Derbyshire’s cabinet member for highways, Cllr Charlotte Hill: “Within six months of Reform taking control in Derbyshire, our council had cleared the entire backlog of potholes.”

Six months into Reform’s control of the council, the authority had a pothole backlog of 3,600, its statistics show.

Meanwhile, this month, Cllr Alan Graves, Reform’s county council leader, shared a post on Facebook saying the authority was exceeding when it came to pothole repair performance.

This post details 28-day pothole repairs were carried out on time in 91 per cent of cases, nine-day pothole repairs were fixed on time in 93.9 per cent of cases, and 32-hour pothole repairs were concluded on time in 90.5 per cent of cases.

He said this showed positive work to cut the original pothole backlog “from around 18,000 repairs in April this year to just 757 at the start of November”.

However, the pothole backlog in April this year was between 10,400-10,700.

This comes after Reform councillors, including councillor Graves, circulated a graphic on Facebook in August claiming to have been carrying out 2,000 pothole repairs per week since they came into office in May 2025, and one repair every eight minutes. But this turned out to just be the-then current rate over the summer of 2026 and not eligible to be extrapolated over the whole year of Reform term in office.

In September, a Government-mandated MOT-style assessment of Derbyshire’s roads found a declining proportion of well-maintained routes, with both fewer “green” rated routes but also “red” rated routes, depending on which criteria were used.

Asked about the Reformer claim, the latest pothole figures and completion targets, Cllr Graves said: “Well done for noticing it appears the starting date is wrong. Instead of May 2026 it should say May 2025 when we took over office. 

“However, the results are accurate in that the outstanding number of potholes have been reduced to an acceptable and manageable level. Cllr Hill was in charge of one of our manifesto commitments and has succeeded.”

Cllr Hill was also approached for comment but did not respond.

Meanwhile, alongside this, the county council had invited a peer challenge review of its highways department carried out by the Local Government Association.

The county council has put out a press release about that independent inspection, saying its summary is that the department is “moving in the right direction”, claiming the quality of repairs, road conditions and planning were “praised”.

It said the council was judged to be “on the right road” and doing good work with recruiting apprentices and graduates and making use of extra funding.

However, the county council has refused to release the assessment carried out by the LGA.

It said there was no report, but a presentation, with a spokesperson saying: “We won’t be providing a copy of the presentation.”

Asked for the reasoning, when a press release had already been issued on the matter, the spokesperson said: “We need time to consider the recommendations and put together an action plan to address them which we will share with the LGA in the coming months for review.”

Written by: Eddie Bisknell - Local Democracy Reporting Service


103.5 & 96.8 FM

LOVE MUSIC

LOVE EREWASH

Office: 0115 888 0968
Studio: 0115 930 3450

Erewash Sound, The Media Centre, 37 Vernon Street, Ilkeston, DE7 8PD

© Copyright 2026 Erewash Sound CIC. All Rights Reserved. Company Number 6658171.